The answer is Fultheim the Fearless and here's why: Very little to no NPCs in Skyrim (as far as I've looked up) share a first name. But you have to know that this will make joining the Brotherhood impossible and Astrid is very difficult to defeat. » Sun Jun 03, 2012 8:24 pm I chose Aleus Quintus because she was so nasty and, with Grelod the Kind no longer running the orphanage I figured her kids were better off without her...why have 5 more just like her in 15 or so years. He claims to be unaware of anyone in particular who would want him dead, but reasons that, being a sell-sword, any number of people could hold a grudge against him. It took me over 6 years of playing Skyrim since it's release to realize this. There are three people held in the shack (screen above): Fultheim the Fearless, Alea Quintus and Vasha. All of the potential victims completely resist poison if the player reverse-pickpockets some onto them, so they must be killed using either a weapon or spell. This is for Premium users only. Which one is it?" Introduction Delayed Burial Innocence Lost With Friends Like These Sanctuary Mourning Never Comes - p. 1 Mourning Never Comes - p. 2 Whispers in the Dark The Silence Has Been Broken Bound Until Death Breaching Security The Cure for Madness - p. 1 The Cure for Madness - p. 2 Recipe for Disaster To Kill an Empire Death Incarnate Hail Sithis! Astrid will offer you a choice. - p. 1 Hail Sithis! If you don't wish to kill Astrid, the room is also occupied by three bound captives. Pre-release reports for Skyrim claimed that the Dark Brotherhood would make you assassinate NPCs whom your character had befriended, which this NPC's association with this quest corroborates. If the player kills Astrid in "With Friends Like These," they'll receive a quest to raid the Dark Brotherhood Sanctuary and kill everyone. Reload a save from before she told you to kill one of the captives. When you activate the Sanctuary's entrance, The Black Door, it will ask, "What is the music of life?" The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim Game Guide by gamepressure.com. Transcript Astrid: Go on, see if you can figure it out. Ironically, given that they're already immobilized, all three captives are immune to paralysis effects. Have fun using it on our WWW pages. You will be welcomed to your new "home" and the door will open. An unused NPC with the placeholder name ". Astrid, of the Dark Brotherhood, informed me that by killing Grelod the Kind, I have robbed her organization of a kill. Thus, you must repay your debt: "A life for a life", as Astrid explains. You can refuse to carry out the job, but you can't avoid killing somebody. Astrid will only give me the key if I kill someone she has taken captive, to … You must now use any bed in the game world. For The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim on the PC, a GameFAQs message board topic titled ""With friends like these..." quest" - Page 5. Also, once one of the captives is killed, the player will never be given the option to release the remaining two - not even after leaving and re-entering the Abandoned Shack: they will remain there, bound and hooded, for all time unless you choose to murder them. She indicates that the tough attitude she has adopted to manage so many children might motivate someone to wish her dead. In truth, it doesn't matter which captive(s) you choose. Astrid will only give me the key if I kill someone she has taken captive, to repay my debt. This is usually the case with quests that have multiple possible outcomes or quests where certain tasks may be done in any order. The entrance to the Dark Brotherhood hideout is hidden among the rocks (screen above), but nevertheless you should not have big problems with finding it. The quest can also sometimes be started after completing Aventus's quest by sleeping in any bed, even before receiving the Mysterious Note from the courier. I have been taken captive and moved to some remote shack. Gate guard will ask you for the password and then you have to choose the first option from the top: Silence, my brother. Make your choice. Conversely, if the player kills a captive first, Astrid becomes "essential" and unkillable, so it is impossible to kill her to get the Abandoned Shack key off her. After the quest "Innocence Lost" has been completed, a courier will appear and give the Dragonborn a note with the imprint of a black hand and the words "We Know" written beneath it. There's no turning back now. Item Guides Top Guide; With Friends Like These… achievement in The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim (Xbox 360) 3: by Frankie DrumsNY: With Friends Like These… achievement in The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim Special Edition (Xbox One) Elder Scrolls V : Skyrim In the quest "With friends Like These" (after killing Grelod the Kind) who did tu kill? Am I to take your silence as Fultheim the Fearless is one of three hostages during the quest "With Friends Like These...."He is a mercenary who was captured from a battlefield. She can be knocked down, and will revert to non-hostile (and full health) when she gets up again), so the player can talk to Astrid to be given the key. She will welcome you to the family by giving you several pieces of Shrouded Armor apparel, which provide enhancements useful to assassins. Speak to Commander Maro in Dragon Bridge southwest of Solitude. Sorry, we've got no plans for mobile versions of this game guide. She gives a brief history on the Brotherhood and also informs you that they have done away with all rules and policies except for one simple principle, "Respect the Family". Astrid will only give me the key if I kill someone she has taken captive, to "repay my debt. Any captives that are spared during the quest remain kneeling with their hood on indefinitely. Travel to any city and talk to a guard. Astrid will give you valuable parts of equipment, which will be very helpful in future killings: Shrouded Armor, Shrouded Boots, Shrouded Gloves and Shrouded Helmet. Description. After waking up in the Abandoned Shack, the, After Astrid's initial speech and before killing any of the captives, you can attempt to pickpocket her if you have the, The rewarded Shrouded Armor consists of a set of. Walk to the Black Gate guarding the access to the hideout and interact with it. Make your kill. I will now never be able to join the shadowy organization of assassins. Stages are not always in order of progress. - p. 9 With Friends Like These Joining the Dark Brotherhood requires the player to kill Grelod the Kind who, contrary to her name, is a rather malicious woman . While waiting for Night Mother, Astrid will send you to meet Nazir, who has several minor contracts for you and now you should be interested in completing this quest (Sanctuary). After getting the correct answer from Astrid, the Black Door will not provide it in the dialogue options when asking for it, thus preventing the player from entering the Sanctuary. It can be received for: Join the Dark Brotherhood After that, go to sleep in a place OTHER THAN Windhelm, and the "With Friends like These" quest will begin when you wake up. However, a certain vampiress will be missing from the scene. While in the Abandoned Shack during the quest With Friends Like These..., kill Astrid instead of a hostage. Is there any way I can retake the quest and kill the DB member instead of one of the captives? Shortly after reaching some other location in the game, a courier should run up to you, giving you a mysterious note (screen above). As you've probably guessed yourself, it doesn't matter which person you kill, because during the conversation Astrid just said that you must kill someone. "Do some people look down on me? I have been taken captive and moved to some remote shack. ", The captive in the center is Alea Quintus, a crass and abrasive mother of six who constantly and irritatingly demands to be released. Why not join us today? In this situation the only solution is to attack the assassin (screen above). Sometimes the quest will not start after sleeping. She will encourage you to introduce yourself to your new family members and give a rundown on how the Brotherhood operates. She will simply just say. But war is war. You have the option of fulfilling the Night Mother's demand for a life by killing Astrid. With Friends Like These - Who Did You Kill and Why? The Dark Brotherhood unlocked quest: Sanctuary. Sheet1 Made By - Showmeyourmajula,Skyrim Conflicting Quests,Original Information - ejnomad07 Conflict,Reason,Solution Quests Requiring Two Games Resolve With Friends Like These... and Destroy the Dark Brotherhood!,You either pick to join the Dark Brotherhood or choose to Destroy it.,None. The assassin will give you key to the Abandoned Shack and invite you to join the Dark Brotherhood, giving you exact location of headquarter and revealing the secret password needed to access it. Skyrim may be steeped in typical fantasy fare, but occasionally it delves into darker material — these quests exemplify Skyrim's scarier elements. It is not required but you can improve your Speech ability this way, because the game will allow you to use persuasion or intimidation. Whether fans are searching for a heroic quest about fighting a dragon or they want to become an all-powerful mage, there are endless paths to explore in this game.For fans of horror, though, Skyrim can be a treat, especially with its dark Daedric Princes and the Dark Brotherhood running free across the providence. Astrid has provided me with the correct passphrase - "Silence, my Brother.". Astrid will reveal that she is currently arranging an important job to give you, and that you should, in the meantime, take care of some routine assassination contracts handled by Nazir. (There are also several other Shrouded Armor pieces on a shelf to the right of the room.) If, for some reason, you want to change your mind and opt out of joining the Dark Brotherhood, do not even try to deny Astrid during the conversation, because it will not work. If you've done everything according to the plan, then during your sleep you'll be captured by Dark Brotherhood member named Astrid and transported to an Abandoned Shack (screen above). Go to the first chamber of the underground hideout, where you'll be welcomed by Astrid (screen above). She didn't want you to determine, which prisoner deserves most to be killed. Skyrim: The 10 Darkest Quests, Ranked. The second step, after Innocence Lost, is to complete the quest "With Friends Like These" to join the Dark Brotherhood. Remove ads and unlock special features. The Dark Brotherhood unlocked quest: With Friends Like These. But as you'll soon find out—should you choose to join the Dark Brotherhood—the contracts placed are, many times, non-obvious and counterintuitive. ", I have killed one of the captives as Astrid instructed, and must now gain entrance to the Dark Brotherhood Sanctuary, which is located in the southern Pine Forest. Astrid will only give me the key if I kill someone she has taken captive, to "repay my debt." I have been taken captive and moved to some remote shack. With Friends Like These… is an achievement in Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim - Special Edition. For The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim on the Xbox 360, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "With friends like these help (spoil)". I have been taken captive and moved to some remote shack. Travel to the Dark Brotherhood Sanctuary and kill all Dark Brotherhood members inside. This page was last modified on 19 December 2020, at 21:04. She will tell you that you cannot leave the room until someone dies. He is the only one of the three who remains calm in the face of imminent death, and mentions that this isn't the first time he's been "bagged and dragged." If an entry is marked as "Finishes Quest" it means the quest disappears from the Active Quest list, but you may still receive new entries for that quest. Copyright © 2000 - 2021 GRY-Online S.A. for gamepressure.com, unofficial game guides, walkthroughs, secrets, game tips, maps & strategies for top games. Related: 10 Difficult Choices That Really Made The Player Think In Skyrim Open your inventory, go to the Books category and take a look at the note, which has an imprint of the hand on it and a sign "We Know". You won't encounter any of them again (unless you return to the shack, and even then you won't be able to learn more). I have killed an innocent person, gained entrance into the Dark Brotherhood Sanctuary, and been officially welcomed into the Dark Brotherhood by Astrid. All of the potential victims completely resist poison if the player reverse-pickpockets some onto them, so they must be killed using either a weapon or spell. With Friends Like These... is a Quest in Skyrim. Subscribe Now If you kill him, Astrid remarks that he was the obvious choice. You can start this quest after you have received a letter from a courier that has a black hand on it with "We know" written under it: After you have received this letter you have to find… You will awaken in an abandoned shack to a greeting from Astrid. Open your quest log: With Friends Like These Astrid, of the Dark Brotherhood, informed me that by killing Grelod the Kind, I have robbed her organization of a kill. You're damn right. He also states that "If one of my enemies wouldn't pay to have me killed, I'd take it as a personal insult.". The amount of time you choose to sleep just before Astrid takes you is irrelevant—no time will pass and your "Hours Slept" statistic will not be updated. Use the key to exit the Abandoned Shack and open the world map. quest. One achievement is unlocked at the end of this quest: The UESPWiki – Your source for The Elder Scrolls since 1995, A Mysterious Note and a Good Night's Sleep, https://en.uesp.net/w/index.php?title=Skyrim:With_Friends_Like_These...&oldid=2286492, Skyrim-Bugs Fixed by the Unofficial Skyrim Patch, Astrid, of the Dark Brotherhood, informed me that by killing Grelod the Kind, I have robbed her organization of a kill. You may also learn that the corpse of the Night Mother is en route to the Sanctuary, though she does not know when it might arrive. Some time after Aventus Aretino rewards you for killing Grelod the Kind and you've left Windhelm, a courier will approach you and deliver a Mysterious Note bearing the ominous words "We know." Astrid invited me into the Dark Brotherhood, but I killed her instead. I just want to observe and admire. If you kill one or more of them, Astrid will give you the password to the Dark Brotherhood Sanctuary's "The Black Door". You will then be given a key to let yourself out of the shack. It is particularly worth to look for additional items useful for an assassin (taking them will not be treated as theft), books improving your abilities and a Word Wall with a Power Word on it. The key required to exit the Abandoned Shack will not appear in Astrid's inventory if you attempt to pick her pocket, but will only appear in her inventory if you kill her. All logos and images are copyrighted by their respective owners. Find Astrid inside. The next time you sleep for any duration, you will "awake after a full sleep" to find that you have been mysteriously transported to unfamiliar surroundings. With Friends Like These... is a quest available in The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim. She will calmly inform you that your killing of Grelod the Kind has pleased the Dark Brotherhood, but that, in doing so, you stole a contract belonging to the Night Mother, the Brotherhood's disembodied spiritual leader. Once you've killed all the captives, you may not be able to interact with Astrid. During conversation with Astrid you'll find out that contract for killing Grelod the Kind was assigned earlier to another Dark Brotherhood assassin, so you've thwarted his designs. Astrid will offer you a choice. When facing them, the captive to the left-hand side is Fultheim the Fearless, a mercenary. Introduction Delayed Burial Innocence Lost With Friends Like These Sanctuary Mourning Never Comes - p. 1 Mourning Never Comes - p. 2 Whispers in the Dark The Silence Has Been Broken Bound Until Death Breaching Security The Cure for Madness - p. 1 The Cure for Madness - p. 2 Recipe for Disaster To Kill an Empire Death Incarnate Hail Sithis! Out of the three contracts, I always assumed the Khajiit was the most likely, since he was the most unlikeable, I was wrong. It is worth 10 points and can be received for: Join the Dark Brotherhood Any text displayed in angle brackets (e.g.. Not all Journal Entries may appear in your journal; which entries appear and which entries do not depends on the manner in which the quest is done. You can now enter the Dark Brotherhood's Sanctuary. It is up to you to figure out which and then carry out the job. You are not permitted to copy any image, text or info from this page. You are a now a full member of the Dark Brotherhood, and enjoy all the advantages associated therewith. The easiest way to get there is to use Fast Travel to the nearby city of Falkret and then head west. Answer with the password Astrid taught you: "Silence, my brother". The courier generally takes between one and three days to arrive, depending on whether the Dragonborn sleeps or if they are close to a town or a … Killing Astrid will lead to unlock the quest Destroy the Dark Brotherhood and you'll find details in its description. Astrid will inform you that "One of these poor sods has a contract out on their life. thanks The following empty quest stages were omitted from the table: 0, 255. The unpickable door to exit the shack is locked, and Astrid has the key. What I would suggest save the game right before you kill one and then reload if you dont like … You can return to your plans of joining the Dark Brotherhood after executing the contract in the quest Innocence Lost and leaving Windhelm. According to the information given by Astrid, the Dark Brotherhood's Sanctuary is located in the southwestern part of Skyrim (screen above). With Friends Like These… is a Bronze in The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim. When intimidated, he also admits, "Maybe there were... times I got carried away? Complete the mission (you can't make a wrong choice--I chose all three and received accolades for it) and the achievement will pop. Astrid says that this murder must be paid back and will demand from you to kill one of the people held in the shack. Kill one of the captives: Astrid, of the Dark Brotherhood, informed me that by killing Grelod the Kind, I have robbed her organization of a kill. Doing this will cause you to fail this quest and immediately start the Destroy the Dark Brotherhood! He does not have any ill thoughts against anyone but many people would put contracts on him due to his occupation that involves killing many people; the relatives of the victims may have a grudge against him. Return to Commander Maro and collect your reward. Fultheim the Fearless will be grateful: Alea Quintus will upbraid you as if you were her kidnapper, even though you're not: and Vasha will merely promise that he won't set his associates on murdering you. Some stages may therefore repeat objectives seen in other stages. The Dark Brotherhood Sanctuary is located almost due south of the Abandoned Shack, near the southern border of the province of Skyrim and just west of Falkreath. You should have a short conversation with each of them. Have I made some enemies? It is important that this bed doesn't belong to anyone else, so choose a bed in friendly fraction hideout, in your house (screen above) or in a tavern. ", The final captive, to the right-hand side, is a Khajiit named Vasha, who casually incriminates himself as an "obtainer of goods, taker of lives, and defiler of daughters." The most obvious solution is to agree for Astrid's demands. If you start this quest before receiving the Mysterious Note, it will never be sent to you. If the player chooses to kill Astrid, any or all of the three captives can be untied and released after Astrid's death. Note - use this free time to familiarize with the entire Dark Brotherhood's Sanctuary. - posted in Skyrim Technical Support: Ok, here is my dilemma, I have talked to the innkeepers to pick the Innocence Lost quest, and killed Grelod the Kind, and returned to Aventus Aretino. Skyrim is a game that can be easily played by a wide range of players. However, if you kill all of them, she'll make a snarky comment that you're an overachiever. Boards The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim With friends like these help (spoil) User Info: wha7leven wha7leven 8 years ago 1. It doesn't matter how long you'll sleep. This site is not associated with and/or endorsed by the Bethesda Softworks or Bethesda Softworks. She finishes by again directing you to Nazir, assigning you your next quest, Sanctuary. "With Friends Like These" Help please! Objective I thought the Dark Brotherhood wasn't actually all that bad but I hate playing it's questline but do not have any safe games older then With Friends Like These I've completed the shed in this save: but I still need to visit the sanctuary. Astrid, Leader of the Dark Brotherhood of Skyrim kidnaps you along with 3 other people, putting you in an abandoned shack in the woods and pressuring you to kill one of them, telling you that one of the people in the cabin has a hit on them and that they have to be eliminated.